GivingTuesday is 1 December: help end violence against women in Africa. Give now
Skip to main content
NGOsource 501(c)(3) Equivalent ACHPR Observer · N°553Observateur CADHP · n° 553 Co-Chair · SEA-T Advisory CouncilCoprésidence · Conseil consultatif SEA-T TransparencyTransparence Candid Platinum Seal 2026Sceau Platinum Candid 2026

Four arguments that apply to every Maputo Protocol reservation

Every reservation to the Maputo Protocol has its own story, yet four legal arguments apply across all nine States. RFLD's report sets them out.

RFLD Team 4 min read
Four arguments that apply to every Maputo Protocol reservation. 4 arguments: Legal arguments RFLD applies across all nine country briefs

The nine States that still limit the Maputo Protocol through reservations or declarations each have their own reasons. Yet some arguments apply to all of them. RFLD’s report Lifting the Reservations: nine country briefs on the Maputo Protocol identifies four such arguments, drawn from treaty law and from the African Commission’s Advocacy Framework, adopted in 2026. Together they form the backbone of every country brief.

1. Object and purpose

Neither the Maputo Protocol nor the African Charter contains an express provision on reservations. The general rules of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties therefore apply. Article 19(c) of that Convention forbids a reservation that is incompatible with the object and purpose of the treaty.

The report defines the object and purpose of the Maputo Protocol as “the elimination of discrimination against women and the guarantee of their rights”. A reservation that removes a core guarantee, such as equality in marriage or access to reproductive health care, sits uneasily with that aim. The Advocacy Framework asks the African Commission to identify which provisions are “core” and cannot be reserved at all.

2. Article 31 makes protective reservations unnecessary

Some States argue that their domestic law protects women better than the Protocol. Article 31 of the Protocol already answers that concern. It provides that more favourable national provisions prevail. The Advocacy Framework describes reservations made on this basis as “superfluous in light of Article 31 of the Protocol”.

This argument applies most directly to South Africa, whose reservations aim to keep South African law more favourable to women. It also applies to parts of Ethiopia’s reasoning. The report’s toolkit puts the point in one line: “Then the reservation is unnecessary.”

3. States with Muslim-majority populations apply the Protocol in full

Some reservations are justified by reference to religion. The Advocacy Framework notes that “at least eight State Parties with majority or significant minority Muslim populations have not made reservations”. They are Djibouti, The Gambia, Libya, Mali, Mauritania, Nigeria, Senegal and Tunisia. The Gambia had made reservations and withdrew them in 2006.

The framework also asks States to avoid cultural relativism and to engage critically with claims that particular provisions contravene Islamic law. The practice of these eight States gives advocates a concrete reference point in that conversation.

4. Declarations that change the law are reservations

Some States describe their statements as declarations or interpretations. The framework applies the test of the UN Human Rights Committee: if a statement, whatever its name, purports to exclude or modify the legal effect of a treaty provision in its application to the State, it is a reservation. This matters for Cameroon’s general declaration and for the interpretive declarations of Ethiopia and South Africa.

What a reservation does not do

Alongside these arguments, the report clears up common misunderstandings about the reach of a reservation. A reservation to the Protocol:

  • does not remove the State’s obligations on equality under the African Charter itself
  • does not prevent the African Commission from asking questions when it examines a State report
  • does not bind other States or treaty bodies
  • does not last forever, since it can be withdrawn at any time

These points matter in practice. They mean that the Commission can raise a reserved provision during a State’s periodic review, and that the African Charter’s equality guarantees continue to apply in full.

A further rule on domestic law

Several reservations rely on domestic legislation. Here the report points to Article 27 of the Vienna Convention, which states that a party may not invoke the provisions of its internal law as justification for its failure to perform a treaty. As the toolkit puts it: “Ratification was a promise to bring the law in line.”

Putting the arguments to work

Each country brief applies these arguments to a specific State, selecting the ones that fit best. The brief on South Africa leans on Article 31. The brief on the Sahrawi Republic draws on the practice of Muslim-majority States Parties and on the State’s own constitutional guarantee of equality. The brief on Algeria rests mainly on object and purpose. The brief on Cameroon applies the Human Rights Committee test.

Advocates preparing submissions to the African Commission can build these arguments into shadow reports. RFLD’s manual on shadow reports under the Maputo Protocol explains how to structure such a submission.

About the report

Cover of the RFLD report Lifting the Reservations: nine country briefs on the Maputo Protocol
Download the full report (PDF, English).

This article draws on RFLD’s report Lifting the Reservations: nine country briefs on the Maputo Protocol, published on 4 October 2026. Read the summary, download the English edition or the French edition.

SharefXinWA
R
Published by
RFLD Team · RFLD

Réseau des Femmes Leaders pour le Développement, a pan-African network for gender equality and development advancing women's rights, SRHR, civic space and climate justice across 35+ African countries since 2013.

For funders and partnersPour les bailleurs et les partenaires

Fund the women who defend rights in Africa, nowFinancez maintenant les femmes qui défendent les droits en Afrique

Aid to women’s organisations is falling. RFLD moves funding fast to women-led organisations and defenders, in French and English, through a network of 1,143 member organisations in more than 35 African countries.L’aide aux organisations de femmes recule. Le RFLD achemine vite les financements vers les organisations de femmes et les défenseures, en français et en anglais, grâce à un réseau de 1 143 organisations membres dans plus de 35 pays africains.

RFLD currently serves as Co-Chair of the SEA-T Programme Advisory Council, mandated to ensure the programme’s direction, priorities, and resources are meaningfully aligned with the visions of African women-led civil society. The SEA-T Programme is funded by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ) and implemented by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH.Le RFLD assure actuellement la coprésidence du Conseil consultatif du programme SEA-T, chargé de veiller à ce que l’orientation, les priorités et les ressources du programme soient réellement alignées sur les visions de la société civile africaine portée par les femmes. Le programme SEA-T est financé par le ministère fédéral allemand de la Coopération économique et du Développement (BMZ) et mis en œuvre par la Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH. See the partnershipVoir le partenariat

  • 1,143member organisationsorganisations membres
  • 35+African countriespays africains
  • N°553ACHPR observer statusstatut d’observateur CADHP
  • CandidPlatinum Seal of Transparency 2026Sceau de transparence Platine 2026

DonateFaire un don Partner with RFLDDevenir partenaire See our financialsVoir nos états financiers

Stay close to the movement.
Field notes, data releases and calls for proposals, in English or French. No more than one email a month.

Across all our workDans tout notre travail

Economic justice and climate justiceJustice économique et justice climatique

Women cannot be safe or equal without land, income and a voice in climate decisions. Economic and climate justice run through every RFLD programme, from ending violence to political leadership and health.Les femmes ne peuvent être en sécurité ni égales sans terre, revenus et voix dans les décisions climatiques. La justice économique et climatique traverse chaque programme du RFLD, de la fin des violences au leadership politique et à la santé.

Economic justiceJustice économiqueLand, work and the care economyLa terre, le travail et l’économie des soinsInheritance and land rights, decent work, credit for women and gender-responsive budgets.Droits successoraux et fonciers, travail décent, crédit pour les femmes et budgets sensibles au genre. Climate justiceJustice climatiqueWomen leading adaptationLes femmes à la tête de l’adaptationWomen-led adaptation, land rights, climate finance that reaches grassroots groups and a just transition.Adaptation menée par les femmes, droits fonciers, finance climatique qui atteint les groupes de base et transition juste. ProgrammeProgrammeRFLD Climate ActionRFLD Climate ActionOur programme for women’s leadership in the climate transition across sub-Saharan Africa.Notre programme pour le leadership des femmes dans la transition climatique en Afrique subsaharienne.
Stand with African women. Your support moves resources to the frontline.Partner with usDonate