GivingTuesday, c’est le 1er décembre : aidez à mettre fin aux violences faites aux femmes en Afrique. Faire un don
Aller au contenu principal
Équivalence 501(c)(3) NGOsource ACHPR Observer · N°553Observateur CADHP · n° 553 Co-Chair · SEA-T Advisory CouncilCoprésidence · Conseil consultatif SEA-T TransparencyTransparence Candid Platinum Seal 2026Sceau Platinum Candid 2026
§ RFLD

Decisions and enforcement: when courts rule on women’s rights in AfricaDécisions et exécution : quand les tribunaux statuent sur les droits des femmes en Afrique

Three landmark African decisions on women's rights, from the ruling to implementation, with compliance data and practical steps for civil society.

Last updated · October 31, 2026

Women won in court. Then what?. Mali 2018, Sierra Leone 2019, DR Congo 2023. RFLD.

Winning a case is only half the work. This module of the Plateforme du Protocole de Maputo follows landmark African decisions on women’s rights, from the ruling to its implementation. It now covers sixteen cases from courts and treaty bodies across West, East, Central and Southern Africa. Each fact sheet gives the court, the facts, what was ordered and what is publicly known about compliance. The last sections explain why so many decisions stay on paper and what civil society can do about it.

Last checked: October 2026. Every fact below comes from the decision itself, from court records or from the organisations that litigated the case. Sixteen cases from eleven countries are covered. Sources are listed at the end.

At a glance: 16 cases and where they stand

The table sums up every case in this module. “Implemented” means the main orders have been carried out. “Partial” means some orders have been carried out and others have not. “Not implemented” means we found no public evidence that the State has acted on the main orders. “Pending” means the case is still before the court.

Country Decision Forum and year Issue Status (October 2026)
Mali APDF and IHRDA v. Mali African Court, 2018 Child marriage, consent, inheritance Not implemented
Sierra Leone WAVES and CWS-SL v. Sierra Leone ECOWAS Court, 2019 Ban on pregnant girls in school Partial
DR Congo S.A. v. DRC (502/14) African Commission, 2023 Reparation for rape by a soldier Not implemented
DR Congo Fizi (686/18) African Commission, 2025 Mass rape by soldiers Not implemented
DR Congo Minova (700/18) African Commission, 2024 Mass rape by soldiers Not implemented
Niger Hadijatou Mani Koraou v. Niger ECOWAS Court, 2008 Slavery and “wahaya” concubinage Compensation reported paid
Nigeria Dorothy Njemanze and others v. Nigeria ECOWAS Court, 2017 Arrest of women labelled sex workers No public confirmation of payment
Nigeria Mary Sunday v. Nigeria ECOWAS Court, 2018 Police failure to prosecute domestic violence No public confirmation of payment
Éthiopie Equality Now and EWLA v. Ethiopia (341/2007) African Commission, 2016 Abduction, rape and forced marriage of a girl No public confirmation of payment
Tanzania LHRC and CRR v. Tanzania (0012/Com/001/2019) ACERWC, 2022 Expulsion of pregnant and married girls Partial
Tanzania Attorney General v. Rebeca Gyumi Court of Appeal, 2019 Marriage age of 15 for girls Not implemented
Zimbabwe Mudzuru and Tsopodzi v. Minister of Justice Constitutional Court, 2016 Child marriage Implemented through the Marriages Act 2022
Kenya C.K. and 11 others (“160 Girls”) High Court, 2013 Police failure to investigate defilement Partial
Kenya Tatu Kamau v. Attorney General High Court, 2021 Challenge to the FGM ban Ban upheld
Ouganda Mifumi v. Attorney General Supreme Court, 2015 Refund of bride price Refund struck down
Gambia Almameh Gibba and others v. Attorney General Supreme Court, filed 2025 Challenge to the FGM ban Pending

Fact sheet 1. Mali, 2018: APDF and IHRDA v. Republic of Mali

The case

  • Court: African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Application No. 046/2016, reported at (2018) 2 AfCLR 380.
  • Applicants: the Association pour le progrès et la défense des droits des femmes maliennes (APDF) and the Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa (IHRDA). The Registry received the application on 26 July 2016.
  • Judgment: 11 May 2018, unanimous. Mali took part in the proceedings and asked the Court to dismiss the case.

The facts

The case challenged Law No. 2011-087 on the Persons and Family Code. The National Assembly adopted it on 2 December 2011 and the President promulgated it on 30 December 2011. Article 281 set the minimum age of marriage at 18 for men and 16 for women. Administrative authorities could allow a girl to marry at 15 for “compelling reasons”. The Code did not ensure that both spouses freely consented to a religious marriage. By default, it applied religious and customary rules to inheritance, which disadvantaged women and children born outside marriage.

What the Court found

  • On the age of marriage, Mali violated Article 6(b) of the Maputo Protocol and Articles 2 and 21 of the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (ACRWC).
  • On consent, Mali violated Article 6(a) of the Maputo Protocol and Article 16(1)(b) of CEDAW.
  • On inheritance, Mali violated Article 21(1) and (2) of the Maputo Protocol and Article 3 of the ACRWC.
  • On harmful practices and discrimination, the Court found further violations of Article 2 of the Maputo Protocol and of the ACRWC. It also found violations of Articles 5(a) and 16(1) of CEDAW.

IHRDA describes this as the first case in which the African Court applied the Maputo Protocol.

What the Court ordered

Mali had to amend the Code and bring its law in line with the treaties it ratified. It also had to inform and educate the public, as Article 25 of the African Charter requires. The Court asked Mali to report on the measures taken within two years.

Implementation

The Code has not been amended. In its implementation status report as at 31 December 2024, the African Court records for Mali: “No information available. No implementation report was received, despite reminders sent to that effect.” IHRDA held a public dialogue in Mali on implementation in March 2023. In 2024, IHRDA told both the African Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child and the African Commission that the orders “remain unfulfilled by the Malian government”. Girls in Mali can still be married at 16.

Fact sheet 2. Sierra Leone, 2019: WAVES and CWS-SL v. Sierra Leone

The case

  • Court: ECOWAS Community Court of Justice, Application ECW/CCJ/APP/22/18, Judgment ECW/CCJ/JUD/37/19 of 12 December 2019, delivered in Abuja.
  • Applicants: Women Against Violence and Exploitation in Society (WAVES) and the Child Welfare Society Sierra Leone (CWS-SL), with Equality Now and IHRDA. They filed the case in May 2018. Amnesty International intervened as amicus curiae.

The facts

During the Ebola crisis, schools closed for nine months and teenage pregnancies rose sharply. In April 2015, the government formally barred pregnant girls from mainstream schools and from sitting exams. The Minister who lifted the ban in 2020 referred to an earlier government decision of 2010. Instead of mainstream classes, the government set up separate schools for pregnant girls. They opened three days a week and taught four subjects. The government at first denied that any policy existed.

What the Court found

The Court held that a sporadic practice had become State policy. The ban and the separate schools were discriminatory and violated the right to education. Equality Now reports findings under the African Charter and under UN treaties, including the UNESCO Convention against Discrimination in Education. The Court also found that the government had not done enough to reduce teenage pregnancy.

What the Court ordered

  • Revoke the ban with immediate effect.
  • Abolish the separate schools for pregnant girls.
  • Run nationwide strategies to change attitudes towards pregnant girls and teenage mothers, so that they can stay in school.
  • Put in place social programmes that address teenage pregnancy and sensitise communities against discrimination.

Implementation

Implementation is partial. On 30 March 2020, the Minister of Basic and Senior Secondary Education announced that the ban was “overturned with immediate effect”. The National Policy on Radical Inclusion in Schools followed in 2021. Parliament enacted the Basic and Senior Secondary Education Act on 24 April 2023, which builds on parts of that policy. Human Rights Watch still found in 2023 that stigma and cost keep many young mothers out of class. ESCR-Net notes that most orders beyond lifting the ban remain unimplemented. At a public dialogue in Freetown in March 2024, IHRDA welcomed “commendable strides” and called for more work towards full implementation.

Fact sheet 3. DR Congo, 2023: S.A. v. Democratic Republic of Congo

The case

  • Body: African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Communication 502/14.
  • Complainants: REDRESS and Synergie pour l’assistance judiciaire aux victimes de violation des droits humains au Nord Kivu (SAJ), on behalf of the survivor. They filed the communication on 21 November 2014. TRIAL filed an amicus brief in 2017.
  • Decision: adopted on the merits in 2023. According to REDRESS, the Commission sent it to the parties on 18 November 2025, which is when it became public. The DRC did not file arguments on the merits.

The facts

On 29 October 2008, during fighting in North Kivu, a sergeant of the Congolese army left the front and went to his home near Goma. At gunpoint, he raped his neighbour, who was two months pregnant. He also took the family’s savings of 120 US dollars and a radio. On 17 November 2008, the Operational Military Tribunal of North Kivu sentenced him to life imprisonment and dismissed him from the army. It ordered him and the State, jointly, to pay 10,000 US dollars in damages. No one appealed, so the judgment became final. The survivor got the radio back. She never received the money. Congolese law prevents enforcement against public assets, which blocks payment by the State.

What the Commission found

The DRC violated Articles 1, 7 and 14 of the African Charter. It also violated Articles 4(2)(f) and 8 of the Maputo Protocol. Article 4(2)(f) requires States to provide reparation for survivors of violence against women. Article 8 guarantees access to justice. The Commission found no separate violation of the prohibition of torture, because Congolese courts had already recognised the State’s responsibility.

What the Commission ordered

  • Execute the military judgment in full, including the sentence.
  • Pay the 10,000 US dollars in damages and the 120 US dollars, with 6% interest from the date of the military judgment.
  • Create a legal and institutional framework to enforce court decisions, including a compensation fund.
  • Report in writing on implementation within 180 days of notification.

Implementation

REDRESS reports that the decision is still pending implementation. We found no public report from the State.

Two further decisions against the DRC

Communication 686/18 (Fizi). On 1 January 2011, Congolese soldiers attacked civilians in Fizi Territory, South Kivu. The communication was filed for 53 survivors, 52 of them women, by the Association des femmes avocates défenseures des droits humains, IHRDA and Equality Now. The decision was transmitted in May 2025. The Commission recognised the sexual violence as torture. It ordered the State to prosecute and punish those responsible within six months and to compensate the survivors. It also ordered care for the survivors and a public apology. Training on women’s rights must reach the armed forces and the justice system. The 180-day reporting deadline passed on 7 November 2025 without a State report, according to REDRESS.

Communication 700/18 (Minova). In 2012 and 2013, retreating Congolese army units committed mass rapes and killings in and around Minova. IHRDA and the same association of women lawyers brought the case for 1,016 identified victims. A military court had acquitted most of the accused in 2014. The Commission adopted its decision in 2024 and disclosed it in April 2025. It found violations of almost every provision claimed and treated the rapes as torture. Its orders include prosecutions and a memorial.

Fact sheet 4. Niger, 2008: Hadijatou Mani Koraou v. Republic of Niger

The case

  • Court: ECOWAS Community Court of Justice, Application ECW/CCJ/APP/08/08, Judgment ECW/CCJ/JUD/06/08 of 27 October 2008.
  • Support: Anti-Slavery International, the Nigerien anti-slavery organisation Timidria and INTERIGHTS.

The facts

In 1996, when she was about 12, Hadijatou Mani was sold for 240,000 CFA francs to a 46-year-old man under the practice known as “wahaya”. A girl of slave descent is bought as a domestic worker and concubine. In 2005, he gave her a “liberation” certificate but then claimed she was his wife. A local court found there had been no marriage. When she married a man of her choice, her former master accused her of bigamy, and she was sentenced to six months in prison.

What the Court found and ordered

The Court found that she had been held in slavery and that Niger was responsible, because its administrative and judicial authorities did not protect her even though slavery is a crime in Niger. It ordered Niger to pay her 10 million CFA francs in compensation.

Implementation

This is one of the rare decisions with a clear positive outcome. According to Anti-Slavery International, she used the compensation to build a house, raise animals, farm land and send her children to school. Niger’s highest court later ruled her “marriage” unlawful. The judgment showed that the ECOWAS Court will hold a State responsible for slavery practised by private individuals. It also showed that the Court accepts cases without the exhaustion of local remedies.

Fact sheet 5. Nigeria, 2017: Dorothy Njemanze and three others v. Nigeria

The case

  • Court: ECOWAS Community Court of Justice, judgment of 12 October 2017, panel presided by Justice Friday Chijioke Nwoke.
  • Applicants: the actress and activist Dorothy Njemanze and three other women arrested in Abuja. The Gender Justice Project of Alliances for Africa coordinated the case, with IHRDA.

The facts

In 2011, soldiers, police officers and officials of the Abuja Environmental Protection Board arrested women on the streets of Abuja at night. They were held without charge and publicly described as prostitutes. The only “evidence” was that they were outside late at night.

What the Court found and ordered

The Court found that the arrests were arbitrary and that the treatment was cruel, inhuman and degrading. It held that the women were targeted because they were women, in breach of the prohibition of discrimination. It stressed that no law forbids a woman to be outside at night. It awarded 6 million naira to each of three applicants, 18 million naira in total.

Implementation

We found no public confirmation that the damages have been paid.

Fact sheet 6. Nigeria, 2018: Mary Sunday v. Nigeria

The case

  • Court: ECOWAS Community Court of Justice, Application ECW/CCJ/APP/26/15, judgment of 17 May 2018.
  • Applicants: the Women Advocates Research and Documentation Centre (WARDC) and IHRDA, on behalf of Mary Sunday. They filed the case in August 2015.

The facts

In August 2012, Mary Sunday’s fiancé, a police officer, beat her and poured boiling stew on her during an argument. She suffered severe burns and lost her ears. No one was prosecuted.

What the Court found and ordered

Nigeria violated her right of access to justice and her right to have her case heard, because it failed to investigate, prosecute and punish the perpetrator effectively. The Court did not find a separate violation of the prohibition of discrimination. It awarded 15 million naira in compensation.

Implementation

We found no public confirmation that the compensation has been paid. The case is often cited to show that a State is responsible when its police protect one of their own.

Fact sheet 7. Ethiopia, 2016: Equality Now and EWLA v. Ethiopia

The case

  • Body: African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Communication 341/2007. The decision was made public in March 2016.
  • Complainants: Equality Now and the Ethiopian Women Lawyers Association (EWLA), on behalf of Woineshet Zebene Negash.

The facts

In 2001, when she was 13, a man broke into her home with accomplices, abducted her and raped her. He was arrested, released on bail and abducted her again. She was forced to sign a “marriage contract” before she escaped. In 2003, a court sentenced him to 10 years in prison and his accomplices to 8 years. Later that year, an appeal court overturned the sentences and all five men were released.

What the Commission found and ordered

Ethiopia failed to protect her from violence and failed to provide an effective justice system. The Commission recommended compensation of 150,000 US dollars and “escalated and targeted measures” against marriage by abduction and rape.

Implementation

We found no public confirmation that the compensation has been paid.

Fact sheet 8. Tanzania, 2022: LHRC and CRR v. Tanzania (pregnant schoolgirls)

The case

  • Body: African Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (ACERWC), Communication 0012/Com/001/2019.
  • Complainants: the Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC) and the Center for Reproductive Rights, on behalf of Tanzanian girls. They filed on 16 June 2019. The Committee held a hearing on 22 November 2021 and decided on 15 September 2022.

The facts

For years, Tanzanian schools forced girls to take pregnancy tests and expelled those who were pregnant or married. Some pregnant girls were also arrested and detained.

What the Committee found and ordered

Tanzania violated the African Children’s Charter, including the rights to non-discrimination, education, health, privacy and protection from harmful practices. The Committee recommended that Tanzania:

  • ban mandatory pregnancy testing in schools and health facilities, and announce the ban publicly;
  • stop expelling pregnant and married girls, and readmit those who were expelled;
  • investigate the detention of pregnant girls and stop arbitrary arrests;
  • provide catch-up support, sexuality education and youth-friendly health services;
  • act against child marriage and support survivors of sexual violence.

Implementation

Implementation is partial. A few days after the November 2021 hearing, the Minister of Education announced that pregnant girls and young mothers could return to school. The complainants kept the case going so that the change would last. The Committee held an implementation hearing on 9 October 2024 at its 44th Ordinary Session. Readmission is now government policy, but the complainants report that the other recommendations, including the ban on pregnancy testing, need more work.

A lesson on choosing a forum

Equality Now and a Tanzanian woman, Tike Mwambipile, brought a similar case to the African Court (Application 042/2020). On 1 December 2022, the Court declared it inadmissible by 8 votes to 2. Under Article 56(7) of the African Charter, the matter had already been “settled” by the ACERWC decision. Two bodies will not decide the same issue twice. Coordinate with other litigants before you file.

Fact sheet 9. Tanzania, 2019: Attorney General v. Rebeca Gyumi

The case

  • Courts: High Court of Tanzania, Miscellaneous Civil Cause No. 5 of 2016 (judgment in 2016). Court of Appeal of Tanzania, Civil Appeal No. 204 of 2017, judgment of 23 October 2019.
  • Petitioner: Rebeca Gyumi, founder of the Msichana Initiative.

What the courts found

Sections 13 and 17 of the Law of Marriage Act of 1971 allowed girls to marry at 15 with parental consent, and at 14 with court permission. Boys had to be 18. The High Court found both sections unconstitutional because they discriminated against girls. It gave the government one year to set 18 as the minimum age for both sexes. The Court of Appeal dismissed the government’s appeal in 2019.

Implementation

The Act has not been amended. Instead of changing the law, the government launched public consultations on the marriage age. Seven years after the final judgment, girls in Tanzania can still be married at 15. Tanzania’s UPR review on 5 November 2026 is a chance to raise this.

Fact sheet 10. Zimbabwe, 2016: Mudzuru and Tsopodzi v. Minister of Justice

The case

  • Court: Constitutional Court of Zimbabwe, judgment of 20 January 2016, [2016] ZWCC 12.
  • Applicants: Loveness Mudzuru and Ruvimbo Tsopodzi, two young women who had been married as children.

What the Court found

Section 78(1) of the 2013 Constitution sets 18 as the age to found a family. The Court held that no person, girl or boy, may enter any marriage, including an unregistered customary union, before 18. It struck down section 22(1) of the Marriage Act, which allowed girls to marry at 16.

Implementation

The ruling took effect immediately. Parliament later passed the Marriages Act of 2022, which sets 18 as the minimum age for all marriages and makes it an offence to marry a child or to pledge a child for marriage. Child marriage remains common in practice, so enforcement is now the challenge. This is one of the clearest examples of a court decision that led to law reform.

Fact sheet 11. Kenya, 2013: C.K. and 11 others v. Commissioner of Police (“160 Girls”)

The case

  • Court: High Court of Kenya at Meru, Petition No. 8 of 2012, judgment of 27 May 2013 by Justice J. A. Makau.
  • Petitioners: 11 girls aged 3 to 17, through Ripples International, representing 160 girls whose reports of defilement had not been investigated. The Equality Effect and Kenyan lawyers supported the case.

What the Court found and ordered

The police had failed to conduct prompt, effective and proper investigations into the girls’ complaints. The Court held that this failure violated the girls’ rights under the Constitution and under regional and international law, and “created a climate of impunity”. It ordered the police to investigate the cases properly and to enforce the law on sexual offences.

Implementation

Implementation is partial. The judgment led to a police training programme run with The Equality Effect. Survivor-led evaluations of the police, the latest published in 2024, still report delays and poor treatment in some stations.

Fact sheet 12. Kenya, 2021: Tatu Kamau v. Attorney General

The case

  • Court: High Court of Kenya, Petition No. 244 of 2019 (formerly Machakos Petition No. 8 of 2017), judgment of 17 March 2021 by a bench of three judges.

What the Court found

A doctor asked the Court to strike down the Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation Act of 2011, arguing that adult women should be free to choose the practice. The Court dismissed the petition. It held that FGM violates the rights to health and dignity, and that consent does not change this, given the social pressure on women and girls.

Why it matters

The judgment protects an existing law against a direct attack. It gives lawyers in other countries, including The Gambia, reasoning they can use.

Fact sheet 13. Uganda, 2015: Mifumi v. Attorney General

The case

  • Court: Supreme Court of Uganda, Constitutional Appeal No. 2 of 2014, judgment of 6 August 2015, [2015] UGSC 13.
  • Appellant: MIFUMI, a Ugandan women’s rights organisation.

What the Court found

By a majority, the Court held that the customary practice of demanding a refund of bride price when a marriage ends is unconstitutional. It found that the refund demand keeps women in abusive marriages and treats them as property. The Court did not ban bride price itself.

Implementation

The ruling applies directly, and courts can no longer enforce a refund. Advocates continue to ask Parliament to regulate bride price by law.

Fact sheet 14. The Gambia, pending: the Supreme Court challenge to the FGM ban

The case

The Women’s (Amendment) Act of 2015 made FGM a crime in The Gambia. In March 2024, an MP tabled a bill to repeal the ban. On 15 July 2024, the National Assembly rejected it. In 2025, MP Almameh Gibba and seven other plaintiffs asked the Supreme Court to declare the ban unconstitutional, arguing that it violates the rights to culture and religion. The Court heard witnesses from December 2025 and through 2026.

Why it matters

At the time of writing, the Court has not delivered its judgment. If the ban falls, The Gambia would be the first country to reverse an FGM ban, and the effect could reach the whole region. Women’s organisations have filed evidence and public statements. The ban also needs enforcement. In May 2026, the High Court acquitted three women charged after a one-month-old baby bled to death following FGM in the West Coast Region.

The enforcement problem

The African Court

Under Article 30 of its Protocol, States undertake to comply with the Court’s judgments within the time set. Article 31 requires the Court to tell the African Union Assembly which States have not complied. In practice, compliance is very low. The Court’s 2024 Activity Report states that of more than 259 decisions adopted, less than 10% have been fully implemented. Its implementation status report as at 31 December 2024 found violations in 89 cases against 10 States. Only 2 of those cases, both against Burkina Faso, had been fully implemented. The other 87 were pending full implementation.

Access is also shrinking. As at 31 December 2024, 34 of the 55 African Union member States had ratified the Court’s Protocol. Only 8 allowed individuals and NGOs to file cases directly under Article 34(6). Rwanda, Tanzania, Benin and Côte d’Ivoire withdrew their declarations between 2016 and 2020.

The ECOWAS Court

The ECOWAS Court has no enforcement arm of its own. Article 24 of its 2005 Supplementary Protocol requires each member State to appoint a national authority to execute judgments, and many have not done so. In October 2025, the Court’s President put enforcement at about 30% of decisions. In December 2025, the Deputy Chief Registrar cited a rate of 22%.

The African Commission

The Commission’s decisions take the form of recommendations to the State. Rule 125 of its 2020 Rules of Procedure sets the follow-up steps:

  • the State must report in writing within 180 days of receiving the decision, and the complainant has 60 days to comment;
  • the Commission can ask for more information within 90 days, and can send a reminder with a further 90 days if the State is silent;
  • a Rapporteur monitors implementation and can consider information from interested parties;
  • the Commission reports publicly at each ordinary session and states the status of implementation in its Activity Report;
  • it can refer cases of non-compliance to the political organs of the African Union.

The record is weak. The best-known study, by Frans Viljoen and Lirette Louw, reviewed 44 decisions adopted between 1987 and 2003. It found full implementation in only 14% of them.

Where to take a case: a forum guide

Each forum has its own rules on who can file and what you must do first. The table gives the main points. Check the latest rules before you file, and coordinate with other litigants so that two bodies are not asked to decide the same matter.

Forum Who can file Main conditions Type of decision
African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (Arusha) The African Commission, States, African intergovernmental bodies. Individuals and NGOs with observer status at the Commission only against the few States that accept Article 34(6). Exhaust local remedies. The matter must not be settled by another body (Article 56(7) of the Charter). Binding judgment. The Court reports non-compliance to the AU Assembly.
African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (Banjul) Any individual or organisation, African or not, including on behalf of a victim. Exhaust local remedies, or show that they are unavailable or ineffective. File within a reasonable time. Recommendations, with a follow-up procedure under Rule 125. The Commission can refer a case to the African Court.
African Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child Individuals, groups and NGOs, for violations against children in States party to the African Children’s Charter. Exhaust local remedies. Concerns girls under 18. Recommendations, with implementation hearings.
ECOWAS Court of Justice (Abuja) Any individual or NGO for violations by an ECOWAS member State. No need to exhaust local remedies. The case must not be pending before another international court. Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger left ECOWAS in January 2025, so new cases against them face serious obstacles. Binding judgment, executed through a national authority under Article 24 of the 2005 Supplementary Protocol.
East African Court of Justice (Arusha) Residents of East African Community States. Strict time limit of two months. Human rights claims must be framed under the rule of law and good governance principles of the EAC Treaty. Binding judgment.
CEDAW Committee (Geneva), Optional Protocol Individuals or groups in a State that has accepted the Optional Protocol. Exhaust domestic remedies. The matter must not be examined by another international procedure. Views and recommendations, with follow-up.
National constitutional and high courts Depends on national law. Many African constitutions allow public interest litigation. National procedure. Binding judgment. Usually the fastest route to law reform.

The SADC Tribunal is not an option for individuals. It was suspended in 2010, and its 2014 Protocol limits it to disputes between States.

Lessons from the cases

  • National courts can move faster. In Zimbabwe and Uganda, constitutional judgments changed the law the day they were delivered. In Tanzania, a final judgment has been ignored for seven years. A domestic victory still needs follow-up.
  • Money is easier to obtain than law reform, but not easy. Niger paid Hadijatou Mani. Most other awards for compensation in this module have no public record of payment.
  • Policy change can come before the decision. Tanzania changed its school policy days after the ACERWC hearing. Litigation creates pressure even before a ruling.
  • Choose one forum per issue. The African Court dismissed the second Tanzanian schoolgirls case because the ACERWC had already decided the matter.
  • Victories need defending. The FGM bans in Kenya and The Gambia were challenged in court. Women’s organisations should be ready to intervene as amicus curiae.
  • Document everything. Strong cases rest on medical records, police reports and court files. Help survivors keep copies from the start.

What civil society can do

  1. Use the follow-up rules. Under Rule 125(6), the Rapporteur can consider information from interested parties. Send short, dated updates on what the State has or has not done. For African Court judgments, share information with the Court’s Registry before it prepares its report to the Assembly.
  2. Bring decisions into every review. Cite unimplemented decisions in shadow reports to the African Commission and to UN bodies. Our CEDAW and UPR calendar shows the next dates for each country.
  3. Work with national institutions. National human rights institutions with affiliate status can report on implementation under Rule 125(2). Ministries of justice and parliamentary committees decide on budgets and law reform.
  4. Organise public dialogues. IHRDA’s dialogues in Mali and Sierra Leone brought officials and civil society together around one judgment. They create a public record of commitments.
  5. Translate and share decisions. Short summaries in national and local languages help survivors know their rights. Always protect survivors’ identities and seek their consent before any public use of their story.
  6. Support the survivors. Reparation takes years. Survivors need health care and legal support while they wait. Complainant organisations in S.A. updated the Commission on the survivor’s health in 2024 and 2025.

Why this matters

The Maputo Protocol is ratified by 46 of the 55 African Union member States. These cases show that its rights can be argued and won before African courts and the African Commission. They also show that a ruling changes little without sustained follow-up. RFLD brings together 1,143 member organisations in more than 35 African countries and holds Observer Status N°553 with the African Commission. We will add new decisions to this module and track State reports on implementation. Members with information on a case can write to programs@rflgd.org.

References

SharefXinWA

Advance gender justice with RFLD

A pan-African network of 1,143 member organisations across 35+ countries: advocacy, research, re-granting and direct service delivery.

For funders and partnersPour les bailleurs et les partenaires

Fund the women who defend rights in Africa, nowFinancez maintenant les femmes qui défendent les droits en Afrique

Aid to women’s organisations is falling. RFLD moves funding fast to women-led organisations and defenders, in French and English, through a network of 1,143 member organisations in more than 35 African countries.L’aide aux organisations de femmes recule. Le RFLD achemine vite les financements vers les organisations de femmes et les défenseures, en français et en anglais, grâce à un réseau de 1 143 organisations membres dans plus de 35 pays africains.

RFLD currently serves as Co-Chair of the SEA-T Programme Advisory Council, mandated to ensure the programme’s direction, priorities, and resources are meaningfully aligned with the visions of African women-led civil society. The SEA-T Programme is funded by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ) and implemented by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH.Le RFLD assure actuellement la coprésidence du Conseil consultatif du programme SEA-T, chargé de veiller à ce que l’orientation, les priorités et les ressources du programme soient réellement alignées sur les visions de la société civile africaine portée par les femmes. Le programme SEA-T est financé par le ministère fédéral allemand de la Coopération économique et du Développement (BMZ) et mis en œuvre par la Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH. See the partnershipVoir le partenariat

  • 1 143member organisationsorganisations membres
  • 35+African countriespays africains
  • N°553ACHPR observer statusstatut d’observateur CADHP
  • CandidPlatinum Seal of Transparency 2026Sceau de transparence Platine 2026

DonateFaire un don Partner with RFLDDevenir partenaire See our financialsVoir nos états financiers

Restez proche du mouvement.
Nouvelles du terrain, publications de données et appels à propositions, en français ou en anglais. Un e-mail par mois au plus.

Across all our workDans tout notre travail

Economic justice and climate justiceJustice économique et justice climatique

Women cannot be safe or equal without land, income and a voice in climate decisions. Economic and climate justice run through every RFLD programme, from ending violence to political leadership and health.Les femmes ne peuvent être en sécurité ni égales sans terre, revenus et voix dans les décisions climatiques. La justice économique et climatique traverse chaque programme du RFLD, de la fin des violences au leadership politique et à la santé.

Economic justiceJustice économiqueLand, work and the care economyLa terre, le travail et l’économie des soinsInheritance and land rights, decent work, credit for women and gender-responsive budgets.Droits successoraux et fonciers, travail décent, crédit pour les femmes et budgets sensibles au genre. Climate justiceJustice climatiqueWomen leading adaptationLes femmes à la tête de l’adaptationWomen-led adaptation, land rights, climate finance that reaches grassroots groups and a just transition.Adaptation menée par les femmes, droits fonciers, finance climatique qui atteint les groupes de base et transition juste. ProgrammeProgrammeRFLD Climate ActionRFLD Climate ActionOur programme for women’s leadership in the climate transition across sub-Saharan Africa.Notre programme pour le leadership des femmes dans la transition climatique en Afrique subsaharienne.
Soutenez les femmes africaines. Votre don fait parvenir des ressources en première ligne.Devenir partenaireFaire un don