Reservations to the Maputo Protocol do not all rest on the same reasoning. Some invoke religion. Others point to domestic law, or to a reform still under way. RFLD’s report Lifting the Reservations: nine country briefs on the Maputo Protocol groups the reservations of the nine States by the reason given, and pairs each group with the argument most likely to answer it.
Why classify reservations at all
A single advocacy message rarely works for every State. A government that believes its law already protects women better needs a different conversation from one that cites religious law. Knowing which type of reservation is in play helps advocates choose the right argument and the right moment.
Religious grounds
The Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic justifies its reservations on the ground that the provisions concerned contravene Islamic law. The counter-argument draws on regional practice. At least eight States Parties with majority or significant Muslim populations apply the Protocol without reservations: Djibouti, The Gambia, Libya, Mali, Mauritania, Nigeria, Senegal and Tunisia.
Domestic law
Several States explain some reservations by reference to their own legislation. Kenya considers the reserved provisions inconsistent with its domestic legislation on health and reproductive rights. Mauritius reserves Article 6(c) where it is incompatible with domestic law. Ethiopia’s reservations on marriage follow the same pattern. The counter-argument is Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties: a party may not invoke its internal law as justification for failing to perform a treaty.
Protective reservations
South Africa, and in part Ethiopia, made reservations meant to keep domestic law more favourable to women. South Africa has abolished the death penalty, for example, so Article 4(2)(j), which only protects pregnant or nursing women from execution, sets a lower bar. The counter-argument is Article 31 of the Protocol, which already preserves more favourable national law. The African Commission’s Advocacy Framework calls such reservations “superfluous”.
Vague reservations or no reason
Algeria reserved entire articles and gave no reason. Some reservations of Ethiopia and Mauritius are also listed by the Advocacy Framework as vague. The counter-argument here is practical: when the scope of a reservation is unclear, it is impossible to know what obligation the State has accepted. The framework asks States to avoid reservations that are “general and vague”.
Interim reservations
Namibia’s reservation to Article 6(d) is openly temporary. Withdrawal depends on legislation on the registration of customary marriages. Here the strategy is to focus on meeting the condition the State set for itself, then to ask for a withdrawal date. The Advocacy Framework encourages States that consider a reservation unavoidable to make it explicitly interim in this way.
Moral values declarations
Cameroon’s general declaration states that acceptance of the Protocol does not mean it endorses practices it considers inconsistent with “universal or African ethical and moral values”. The counter-argument is the test of the UN Human Rights Committee: a declaration that excludes or modifies the legal effect of a provision operates as a reservation, whatever it is called.
Summary table in words
- Religious grounds: answered by the practice of Muslim-majority States Parties.
- Domestic law: answered by Article 27 of the Vienna Convention.
- Protective: answered by Article 31 of the Protocol.
- Vague or unexplained: answered by the need for a clear scope of obligation.
- Interim: answered by meeting the State’s own stated condition.
- Moral values declarations: answered by the Human Rights Committee test.
One State, several types
Some States fall into more than one group. Ethiopia’s list mixes reservations based on domestic law with others the framework calls vague. Mauritius has both domestic-law and vague reservations. For these States, advocates can work provision by provision, starting where the counter-argument is strongest.
Underneath all the types sits one general rule. Article 19(c) of the Vienna Convention forbids any reservation that is incompatible with the object and purpose of a treaty. For the Maputo Protocol, that object and purpose is the elimination of discrimination against women and the guarantee of their rights.
Each country brief in the report applies this typology to a specific State, with questions for dialogue and asks for each actor. The report summary gives an overview of all nine.
About the report

This article draws on RFLD’s report Lifting the Reservations: nine country briefs on the Maputo Protocol, published on 4 October 2026. Read the summary, download the English edition or the French edition.
